Determining weights of comprehensive evaluation indexes for irrigation district operation performance by method of game theory
Fei Liangjun1, Wang Guangshe2, Sun Jie 1,3, Feng Chanli2, Xie Fang1
1.Water Resources Research Institute, Xi′an University of Technology, Xi′an, Shaanxi 710048, China; 2.Shaanxi Province Institute of Water Resources and Electric Power Investigation and Design, Xi′an, Shaanxi 710001, China; 3.Xi′an Research Institute, China Coal Technology and Engineering Group, Xi′an, Shaanxi 710077, China
Abstract：In order to decide if the weight of an index for comprehensive evaluating operation perfor-mance of irrigation district is reasonable and to consider whether the outcomes of an evaluation are rational and scientific, we apply subjective analytic hierarchy process and objective variation coefficient method into determination of a series of weight based on game theory in this paper. Then we integrate these individual weights into final weights. Further, based on the driving force-state-response model, we build a comprehensive evaluation system to assess the operational performance of a large irrigation district. At last, we evaluate the operational condition of Jinghui Canal Irrigation District in Shaanxi by means of this system. The results show that the decided comprehensive weights can involve decision-makers′ subjective requirements but also can represent the actual operational circumstance of an irrigation district. Besides, the evaluating process is simple, scientific, objective, and universal, so it can provide a proper evaluation for the operational situation of an irrigation district.
费良军, 王光社, 孙洁,, 冯缠利, 谢芳. 基于博弈论法确定灌区运行状况综合评价指标的权重[J]. 排灌机械工程学报, 2014, 32(9): 808-813.
Fei Liangjun, Wang Guangshe, Sun Jie ,, Feng Chanli, Xie Fang. Determining weights of comprehensive evaluation indexes for irrigation district operation performance by method of game theory. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engin, 2014, 32(9): 808-813.
[1]朱秀珍,崔远来,李远华,等.灌区运行状况综合评价权重系数的确定[J].灌溉排水学报,2004,23(1):10-13. Zhu Xiuzhen, Cui Yuanlai, Li Yuanhua, et al. Weight vector definition in bench marking of irrigation system performance[J]. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage,2004,23(1):10-13.(in Chinese)[2]王书吉.大型灌区节水改造项目综合后评价指标权重确定及评价方法研究[D].西安:西安理工大学西北水资源与环境生态教育部重点实验室,2009.[3] 郭亚军.综合评价理论与方法[M].北京:科学出版社,2002.[4] 张颖超,周媛,刘雨华.基于范数灰关联度的指标权重确定方法[J].统计与决策,2006(1):20-21. Zhang Yingchao, Zhou Yuan, Liu Yuhua. Indicators rights norm gray relational degree method for determining weight[J].Statistics and Decision,2006(1):20-21.(in Chinese)[5]Okada H, Styles S W, Grismer M E.Application of the analytic hierarchy process to irrigation project improvement—PartⅡ:How professionals evaluate an irrigation project for its improvement[J].Agricultural Water Mana-gement,2008,95(3):205-210.[6]舒卫萍,崔远来.层次分析法在灌区综合评价中的应用[J].中国农村水利水电,2005(6):109-111. Shu Weiping,Cui Yuanlai. Analytic hierarchy process comprehensive evaluation of irrigation[J]. China Rural Water and Hydropower,2005(6):109-111.(in Chinese)[7]刘雨华.基于梯形模糊数的指标权重确定方法的应用研究[J].南京信息工程大学学报:自然科学版,2009,1(4):369-372. Liu Yuhua. Study on application of the method of determining index weights based on trapezoidal fuzzy numbers[J]. Journal of Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology: Natural Science Edition,2009,1(4):369-372.(in Chinese)[8]储莎,陈来.基于变异系数法的安徽省节能减排评价研究[J].中国人口资源与环境,2011,21(3):512-516. Chu Sha, Chen Lai. Evaluation of energy saving and emission reduction of Anhui based on variance coefficient approach[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 2011,21(3):512-516.(in Chinese)[9]郭璐芸,刘蓓蕾.基于变异系数法的上市公司经营业绩灰色关联评价[J].统计与决策,2005(2):18-19. Guo Luyun, Liu Beilei. Coefficient of variation of listed companies operating performance evaluation based on gray relational[J]. Statistics and Decision,2005(2):18-19.(in Chinese)[10]郭文强,安裕伦,刘世曦.基于变异系数法的贵州省石漠化驱动力研究[J].安徽农业科学,2011,39(15):9158-9159,9223. Guo Wenqiang, An Yulun, Liu Shixi. Study on the driving forces of rocky desertification in Guizhou Pro-vince based on variation coefficient method[J]. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2011,39(15): 9158-9159,9223.(in Chinese)[11]游黎.大型灌区运行状况综合评价指标体系与评价方法研究[D].西安:西安理工大学西北水资源与环境生态教育部重点实验室,2010.[12]马涛.灌区运行状况及可持续发展评价研究[D].沈阳:沈阳农业大学水利学院,2008.[13]王正环. 一种改进的DSR模型[J]. 三明学院学报, 2008,25(2):236-240. Wang Zhenghuan. An improved DSR model[J]. Journal of Sanming University, 2008,25(2):236-240.(in Chinese)
