Status of study on single channel centrifugal pumps and its developing tendency
FENG Jinsheng1, LIU Houlin1, DING Jian1, WU Xianfang2, DONG Liang1
1.National Research Center of Pumps, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu 212013, China; 2.School of Energy and Power Engineering, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu 212013, China
Abstract：The application and structure of single channel centrifugal pumps are presented briefly. Then, the status of study on hydraulic design method, energy prediction model and unsteady fluid flow characteristics is outlined and summarized based on previous works achieved in China and abroad. Finally, the development trend of study on single channel centrifugal pump is prospected according to the current research results. Aiming at the strong unsteady characteristics inside the single channel of the centrifugal pump, it is essential to establish a formula for solving the slip factor within a full range of flow rate, and modify and update the existing formula for energy loss models, as well as develop an energy performance prediction model for the single channel pump. Based on a slip factor and performance prediction model, hydraulic design methods for single channel impellers can be put forward. Hence, the important issues in the study on single channel centrifugal pumps should include more extensive investigations into unsteady fluid flow characteristics, establishing more accurate energy performance prediction model and developing perfect design methods.
冯进升, 刘厚林, 丁剑, 吴贤芳, 董亮. 单流道离心泵的研究现状及发展趋势[J]. 排灌机械工程学报, 2017, 35(3): 207-215.
FENG Jinsheng, LIU Houlin, DING Jian, WU Xianfang, DONG Liang. Status of study on single channel centrifugal pumps and its developing tendency. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engin, 2017, 35(3): 207-215.
[1]关醒凡,张晓峰.单流道泵的设计研究[J].排灌机械,1989,7(3),1-3. GUAN Xingfan,ZHANG Xiaofeng.Design on the single channel pump[J].Drainage and irrigation machinery,1989,7(3),1-3.(in Chinese)[2]关醒凡,李幼康,李红,等.单流道泵设计方法[J].江苏工学院学报,1993,14(4):24-29. GUAN Xingfan,LI Youkang,LI Hong,et al.Design procedure of single-channel pump[J]. Journal of Jiangsu Institute of Technology,1993,14(4):24-29.(in Chinese)[3]关醒凡,朱荣生.单流道泵试验研究[J].农业工程学报,1994,10(3):116-120. GUAN Xingfan,ZHU Rongsheng.Experiment on the single channel pump[J].Transactions of the CSAE,1994,10(3):116-120.(in Chinese)[4]关醒凡,张涛,魏东,等.无堵塞泵设计及结构研究[J].排灌机械,2003,21(4):1-4. GUAN Xingfan,ZHANG Tao,WEI Dong,et al.Advances in non-clogging pumps[J].Drainage and irrigation machinery,2003,21(4):1-4.(in Chinese)[5]沙毅,王劲松.单流道污水污物泵设计[J].排灌机械,1997,15(3):11-14. SHA Yi,WANG Jinsong.Design of single channel sewage pump [J].Drainage and irrigation machinery,1997,15(3):11-14.(in Chinese)[6]刘厚林,马皓晨,关醒凡.单流道叶轮水力设计方法的研究[J].农业工程学报,2001,17(4):52-55. LIU Houlin,MA Haochen,GUAN Xingfan.Study on hydraulic design method of single channel impeller[J].Transactions of the CSAE,2001,17(4):52-55.(in Chinese)[7]NISHI Y,FUJIWARA R,FUKUTOMI J.Design method for single-blade centrifugal pump impeller[J].Journal of fluid science and technology,2009,4(3):786-800.[8]PFLEIDERER I C.Die kreiselpumpen[M].Berlin Heidelberg:Springer,1924.[9]TURTON R K.Rotodynamic pump design[M].New York:Cambridge University Press,1994.[10]LOBANOFF V S,ROSS R R.Centrifugal pumps:design and application[M].Houston:Gulf Professional Publishing,1992.[11]SRINIVASAN K M.Rotodynamic pumps(centrifugal and axial)[M].New Delhi:New Age International,2008.[12]陈宣荣.单叶片污水泵叶轮型线探讨[J].排灌机械,1992,10(1):16-18. CHEN Xuanrong.Discussion of impeller profile on the single channel sewage pump[J].Drainage and irrigation machinery,1992,10(1),16-18.(in Chinese)[13]范宗霖,沈亦晨,毛罕.单通道污水泵的实践与探讨[J].水泵技术,2002(3):9-13. FAN Zonglin,SHEN Yichen,MAO Han.Practice and discussion of single channel sewage pump[J].Pump technology,2002(3):9-13.(in Chinese)[14]关醒凡.现代泵技术手册[M].北京:中国宇航出版社,2011.[15]西泰行,藤原亮太,福富純一郎.一枚羽根遠心羽根車の設計法に関する研究(流体工学,流体機械)[J]. 日本機械学會論文集(B編),2009,75(4):1320-1328.[16]NISHI Y, FUKUTOMI J,FUJIWARA R.Effect of blade outlet angle on radial thrust of single-blade centrifugal pump[C]//Proceedings of the IOP Conference Series:Earth and Environmental Science.[S.l.]: IOP Publishing,2012,15(7):072039.[17]BÜSEMANN A.Das förderhöhenverhältnis radialer kreiselpumpen mit logarithmisch-spiraligen schaufeln[J].Zeitschrift für angewan-dte mathematik und mechanik,1928,8(5):372-384.[18]von BACKSTRÖM T W.A unified correlation for slip factor in centrifugal impellers[J].Journal of turbomachinery,2006,128(1):1-10.[19]von BACKSTRÖM T W.A compact equation for the prediction of eddy-induced slip in centrifugal impellers[J].Journal of power and energy,2006,220(8):911-915.[20]von BACKSTRÖM T W.Relative-eddy induced slip in centrifugal impellers for engineering students[J].R&D Journal of the south African institution of mechanical engineering,2007,23(1):21-27.[21]SPANNHAKE W.A die leistungsaufnahme einer parallelkränzigen zentrifugalpumpe[J].Festschrift der technische hochschule karlsruhe,1925:387-400.[22]NISHI Y,MAKITA K,FUKUTOMI J.A study on a new type of sewage pump[J].Transactions of the Japan society of mechanical engineers,2006,18(8):1984-1992.[23]NISHI Y,MATSUO N,FUKUTOMI J.Loss analysis of a new type of sewage pump[J].Journal of environment and engineering,2009,4(2):362-374.[24]SIEKMANN H,STARK M.Analytical and experimental study of the hydrodynamic unbalance of single-vane impellers[C]//Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Transport Phenomena and Dynamics of Rotating Machinery. Honolulu,HI:[s.n.],1990:D-28A.[25]STARK M.Auslegungskriterien für radiale abwasser-pumpenlaufräder mit einer Schaufel und unterschiedlichem Energieverlauf[J].Forschung im ingenieurwesen,1991,57(2):72-72.[26]ULBRICH C.Experimentelle untersuchung der pumpencharakte-ristiken und geschwindigkeitsfelder einer einschaufel-kreisel-pumpe[D].Berlin:Dissertation TU,1997.[27]SOUZA B D,NIVEN A,DALY J.Single-blade impeller development using the design of experiments method in combination with numerical simulation[J].Journal of process mechanical engineering,2008,222(3):135-142.[28]西泰行,福富純一郎.らせん状吸込流路を有する一枚羽根遠心ポンプのラジアルスラストに及ぼす羽根出口幅の影響[J].ターボ機械,2011,39(1):47-56.[29]AOKI M.Instantaneous interblade pressure distributions and fluctuating radial thrust in a single-blade centrifugal pump[J].Bulletin of JSME,1984,233(27):2413-2420.[30]康灿,沙毅.单流道泵叶轮内部流场分析与性能试验[J].水泵技术,2004(2):21-23. KANG Can,SHA Yi.Turbulence analysis and experiments of single channel pump[J].Pump technology,2004(2):21-23.(in Chinese)[31]ZWINGENBERG M,BENRA F.Measurement of the periodic unsteady flow in a single blade centrifugal pump by PIV method[C]//Proceedings of the 4th WSEAS International Conference on Fluid Mechanics and Aerodynamics. Elounda, Greece:[s.n.],2006:325-330.[32]BENRA F K,DOHMEN H J.Investigation on the time-variant flow in a single-blade centrifugal pump[C]//Proceedings of the 5th WSEAS International Conference on Fluid Mechanics,2008.[33]DALY J, SOUZA B D,NIVEN A,et al.Numerical simulation of transient flow and head distribution through a single blade centrifugal pump impeller[C]//Procee-dings of the 4th WSEAS International Conference on Fluid Mechanics and Aerodynamics, 2006:343-348.[34]NISHI Y,MATSUO N,FUKUTOMI J.A study on internal flow in a new type of sewage pump(1st report: comparison between experiment and CFD calculation)[J].Journal of fluid science and technology,2009,4(3):648-660.[35]NISHI Y,MATSUO N,FUKUTOMI J.A study on internal flow in a new type of sewage pump(2nd report:influence of impeller blade loading and volute casing)[J].Journal of fluid science and technology,2009,4(3):661-672.[36]BENRA F K,DOHMEN H J,SOMMER M.Periodically unsteady flow in a single-blade centrifugal pump:numerical and experimental results[C]//Proceedings of the ASME 2005 Fluids Engineering Division Summer Meeting,2005:1223-1231.[37]PEI J,YUAN S,YUAN J.Fluid-structure coupling effects on periodically transient flow of a single-blade sewage centrifugal pump[J].Journal of mechanical science and technology,2013, 27(7):2015-2023.[38]BÖKE J.Experimentelle und theoretische untersuchungen der hydraulischen kräfte an einschaufeligen laufrädern von abwasserpumpen unter berücksichtigung der anderung geometrischer parameter[M].Berlin:Shaker,2000.[39]AUVINEN M, JUUSELA J A,ILVES L,et al.Dissecting a complex system:a computational study of flow behavior in a single-blade pump[C]//Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Heat Transfer,Fluid Mechanics and Thermodynamics,2007:AM3.[40]AUVINEN M, JUUSELA J A,PEDERSEN N,et al.Time-accurate turbomachinery simulations with open-source CFD:flow analysis of a single-channel pump with openFOAM [C]//Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on Computational Fluid Dynamics. Lisbon, Portugal:[s.n.], 2010.[41]BENRA F K,DOHMEN H J,SOMMER M.Periodically unsteady flow in a single-blade centrifugal pump:numerical and experimental results[C]//Proceedings of the ASME 2005 Fluids Engineering Division Summer Meeting,2005:1223-1231.[42]BENRA F K,DOHMEN H J,SCHNEIDER O.Calculation of hydrodynamic forces and flow induced vibrations of centrifugal sewage water pumps[C]//Proceedings of the ASME/JSME 2003 4th Joint Fluids Summer Engineering Conference,2003:603-608.[43]PEI J,YUAN S Q,BENRA F K,et al.Numerical prediction of unsteady pressure field within the whole flow passage of a radial single-blade pump[J].Journal of fluids engineering,2012, 134(10):101103.[44]BACHMANN P.Fortschritte im erfassen und auswerten von kräften und momenten an rotoren hydraulischer modell-turbo-maschinen[J].Escher wyss mitt,1980:69-81.[45]LIESS C. Die ermittlung dynamischer radialkräfte in hydraulischen maschinen[J].Voith forsch konstruktion,1982,3:1-3.[46]IVERSEN H W,ROLLING R E,CARLSON J J.Volute pressure distribution,radial force on the impeller, and volute mixing losses of a radial flow centrifugal pump[J].Journal of engineering for gas turbines and power,1960,82(2):136-143.[47]BIHELLER H J.Radial force on the impeller of centrifugal pumps with volute,semivolute,and fully concentric casings[J].Journal of engineering for gas turbines and power,1965,87(3): 319-322.[48]GROTRIAN J M.Untersuchungen der radialkraft auf das laufrad einer kreiselpumpe bei verschiedenen spiralgehäuseformen [D].Berlin:TU Braunschweig,1972.[49]GONZÁLEZ J,SANTOLARIA C,PARRONDO J L,et al.Unsteady radial forces on the impeller of a centrifugal pump with radial gap variation[C]//Proceedings of the ASME/JSME 4th Joint Fluids Summer Engineering Conference,2003:1173-1181.[50]GONZÁLEZ J, PARRONDO J L,SANTOLARIA C,et al.Steady and unsteady radial forces for a centrifugal pump with impeller to tongue gap variation[J].Journal of fluids engineering,2006,128(3): 454-462.[51]AGOSTINELLI A,NOBLES D,MOCKRODGE C R.An experimental investigation of radial thrust in centrifugal pumps[J].Journal of engineering for gas turbines and power,1960,82(2):120-125.[52]BOLLETER U,WYSS A,WELTE I,et al.Measurement of hydrodynamic interaction matrices of boiler feed pump impellers[J].Journal of vibration and acoustics,1987,109(2):144-151.[53]BOLLETER U,FREI A,FLORJANCIC S,et al.Rotor dynamic modeling and testing of boiler feedpumps[R].Electric Power Research Institute,Palo Alto,Switzerland,1992.[54]NYIRENDA P J.Experimental study of hydrodynamic forces in mixed flow pumps[D].Eindhoven,the Netherlands:Technische Universiteit Eindhoven,2003.[55]van ESCH B P M.Performance and radial loading of a mixed-flow pump under non-uniform suction flow[J].Journal of fluids engineering,2009,131(5):51-101.[56]PASINI A,TORRE L,CERVONE A,et al.Rotordynamic forces on a four bladed inducer[C]//Proceedings of the 46th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Confere-nce, 2010:5390-5405.[57]GUINZBURG A,BUSE F W.Magnetic bearings as an impeller force measurement technique[C]//Proceedings of the International Pump Users Symposium,1995:69-76.[58]REUNANEN A,LARJOLA J.Radial forces in a centrifugal compressor:experimental investigation by using magnetic bearings and static pressure distribution[J].Journal of thermal science,2005,14(1):1-8.[59]西泰行,牧田晃一,福富純一郎.汚水用新型ポンプに関する研究[J].日本機械学会論文集(B編),2006,720(72):1984-1992.[60]SAVILIUS N, BENRA F K.Experimental investigation of transient hydrodynamic forces of a single-blade centrifugal pump[C]//Proceedings of the 4th WSEAS International Conference on Fluid Mechanics and Areodynamics,2006:331-336.[61]陈红勋,马峥.单流道泵内部流动研究方法探讨[J].上海大学学报(自然科学版),2004,10(4):371-375. CHEN Hongxun,MA Zheng. Study on the internal flow in single vane pump[J].Journal of Shanghai University(natural science edition),2004,10(4):371-375.(in Chinese)[62]邹雪莲,陈红勋.单流道泵叶轮水力径向力的数值计算[J].流体机械,2006,34(1):23-26. ZOU Xuelian,CHEN Hongxun.Numerical calculation of the hydraulic radial force of impeller within the single channel pump[J].Fluid machinery,2006,34(1):23-26.(in Chinese)[63]BENRA F K,SOMMER M.Comparison of calculated and measured hydrodynamic forces of a centrifugal sewage water pump [C]//Proceedings of the Conference on Experiments/Process/System Modelling, 2005.[64]NISHI Y,FUKUTOMI J,FUJIWARA R.Radial thrust of single-blade centrifugal pump [C]//Proceedings of the ASME-JSME-KSME 2011 Joint Fluids Conference Engineering,2011:43-51.[65]NISHI Y,FUKUTOMI J,SAKAI M.Study on unsteady hydrodynamic force of closed-type centrifugal pump with single-blade[J].Transactions of the Japan society of mechanical engineers(series B),2012,788(78):837-849.[66]NISHI Y,FUKUTOMI J.Effect of blade outlet angle on unsteady hydrodynamic force of closed-type centrifugal pump with single blade[J].International journal of rotating machinery,2014:838627.
